Page 1 of 2

Oh, RATS!!! Yos 4 upsets TWAIN again

Posted: Sat Aug 15, 2015 6:47 pm
by watcombeman
When I moved up from Mavericks to Yosemite 2, TWAIN ceased to work properly when called by GC. I complained vociferously about it at the time, as I’m sure Thorsten will remember.The symptoms were that after TWAIN was invoked, either by menu or Command-T, there was a two minute wait until the Canon Scangear window opened. After that, all proceeded normally. This happened every time TWAIN was called.The upgrade to Yos 3 seemed to cure this; there was often a delay of a few seconds before the Scangear window opened, but what the heck.This morning I upgraded to Yos 4, and the problem is back :-( I timed the delay with a stopwatch; it came to 2 minutes 12.9 seconds.Canon’s MP Navigator EX, which also uses TWAIN to call Scangear, has worked perfectly throughout. No delay at all.I checked Activity Monitor, which showed almost identical behaviour to that in Yos 2 - both Graphic Converter and Image Capture Extension “Not responding”, but whereas in Yos 2 I was seeing some 3000 idle wakeups per whatever, this time there was no such frenetic activity.The cure appears to be the same as in Yos 2 - use Activity Monitor to Quit Image Capture Extension. Scangear then opens at once when requested by GC. MP Navigator Ex is unaffected by this drastic surgery, but of course Image Capture becomes useless until I Restart. Fortunately I don’t use Image Capture.I remain of the opinion that there is there is some field in the GC/TWAIN interface which GC is either not setting or is setting imperfectly but which MP Navigator EX gets right. But I do not have the tools, skills or time to acquire either so that I can check (if indeed this is possible).But don’t worry, Thorsten, I know your opinion of TWAIN and I am not expecting you to revisit the interface :-)It will be interesting to see what happens when El Capitain comes out...John.

Re: Oh, RATS!!! Yos 4 upsets TWAIN again

Posted: Sat Aug 15, 2015 6:48 pm
by thorstenlemke
Dear John,the main issue are the drivers.Canon should provide current compatible drivers.Thorsten It will be interesting to see what happens when El Capitain comes out...

Re: Oh, RATS!!! Yos 4 upsets TWAIN again

Posted: Sat Aug 15, 2015 7:58 pm
by Petur Rasmussen
Canon has issued new drivers compatible with Yosemite. --------------------------------------------------------Petur Rasmussen            e-mail: prasm@internet.isSa�lheimum 23, 7A                     Tlf.: +354-553 2858IS-104  Reykjava�k                      Mobil: +354-822 0645  On 15. a�ga�. 2015, at 15:48, Thorsten Lemke lemke@lemkesoft.de [gcmac] <gcmac@yahoogroups.com> wrote:   Dear John,the main issue are the drivers.Canon should provide current compatible drivers.ThorstenIt will be interesting to see what happens when El Capitain comes out...

Re: Oh, RATS!!! Yos 4 upsets TWAIN again

Posted: Sat Aug 15, 2015 9:02 pm
by thorstenlemke
Attachments :Hello,maybe they use now image capture? Did you try?Thorsten Canon has issued new drivers compatible with Yosemite.

Re: Oh, RATS!!! Yos 4 upsets TWAIN again

Posted: Sat Aug 15, 2015 9:10 pm
by Mike Bauers
I hope so,  I have a very nice scanner Cannon dropped drivers for, about three OS versions ago. I have to keep an older OS system going to be able to use that scanner. I have another Canon scanner that does work with the current OS, it's not as featured as the other Canon scanner with the older drivers.Mike BauersSent from my iPhone On Aug 15, 2015, at 11:58 AM, "Petur Rasmussen > wrote: Canon has issued new drivers compatible with Yosemite.

Re: Oh, RATS!!! Yos 4 upsets TWAIN again

Posted: Sun Aug 16, 2015 11:55 am
by John Hill
I consulted Canon during the Yos 2 research into the problem, and they state categorically that they use TWAIN and nothing else to interface their MP Navigator EX software with my printer.Providing I leave Image Capture Extension running, I can use Image Capture with the scanner, but the images are of poorer quality (at least for my purposes) than those obtained with the Canon drivers.It remains to be seen what happens when El Capitan is released, but I imagine they will update the MD5150 drivers. I don’t think it is in their current catalogue, but it is too recent to become obsolescent yet.John. On 15 Aug 2015, at 19:01, Thorsten Lemke lemke@lemkesoft.de [gcmac] <gcmac@yahoogroups.com> wrote:Hello,maybe they use now image capture? Did you try?ThorstenCanon has issued new drivers compatible with Yosemite.

Re: Oh, RATS!!! Yos 4 upsets TWAIN again

Posted: Sun Aug 16, 2015 11:55 am
by John Hill
Yes, they were updated for Yosemite last autumn and I have had them installed from the outset. On 15 Aug 2015, at 17:58, Petur Rasmussen prasm@internet.is [gcmac] <gcmac@yahoogroups.com> wrote:Canon has issued new drivers compatible with Yosemite.--------------------------------------------------------Petur Rasmussen            e-mail: prasm@internet.isSa�lheimum 23, 7A                     Tlf.: +354-553 2858IS-104  Reykjava�k                      Mobil: +354-822 0645 On 15. a�ga�. 2015, at 15:48, Thorsten Lemke lemke@lemkesoft.de [gcmac] <gcmac@yahoogroups.com> wrote: Dear John,the main issue are the drivers.Canon should provide current compatible drivers.ThorstenIt will be interesting to see what happens when El Capitain comes out...

Re: Oh, RATS!!! Yos 4 upsets TWAIN again

Posted: Sun Aug 16, 2015 12:12 pm
by Petur Rasmussen
I am perfectly able to use twain with the Canon driver. Maybe it uses the special Canon environment set up by Canon on installing the driver.Give it another try.RegardsPetur --------------------------------------------------------Petur Rasmussen            e-mail: prasm@internet.isSa�lheimum 23, 7A                     Tlf.: +354-553 2858IS-104  Reykjava�k                      Mobil: +354-822 0645  On 16. a�ga�. 2015, at 08:31, John Hill john@yclept.wanadoo.co.uk [gcmac] <gcmac@yahoogroups.com> wrote:   I consulted Canon during the Yos 2 research into the problem, and they state categorically that they use TWAIN and nothing else to interface their MP Navigator EX software with my printer.Providing I leave Image Capture Extension running, I can use Image Capture with the scanner, but the images are of poorer quality (at least for my purposes) than those obtained with the Canon drivers.It remains to be seen what happens when El Capitan is released, but I imagine they will update the MD5150 drivers. I don’t think it is in their current catalogue, but it is too recent to become obsolescent yet.John.On 15 Aug 2015, at 19:01, Thorsten Lemke lemke@lemkesoft.de [gcmac] <gcmac@yahoogroups.com> wrote:Hello,maybe they use now image capture? Did you try?ThorstenCanon has issued new drivers compatible with Yosemite.

Re: Oh, RATS!!! Yos 4 upsets TWAIN again

Posted: Sun Aug 16, 2015 6:34 pm
by John Hill
It may depend on the Mac - mine is a mid 2007 iMac, the oldest that can use Yosemite.But I have researched this pretty intensively with Yosemite 2 and don’t propose to spend any significant time on it now it has returned with Yos 4.Apart from installing the latest Canon software (drivers and applications), which I have, there isn’t much I can do. The install CD that came with the printer refuses to run - it merely tells me to do just that.John. On 16 Aug 2015, at 10:12, Petur Rasmussen prasm@internet.is [gcmac] <gcmac@yahoogroups.com> wrote:I am perfectly able to use twain with the Canon driver. Maybe it uses the special Canon environment set up by Canon on installing the driver.Give it another try.RegardsPetur--------------------------------------------------------Petur Rasmussen            e-mail: prasm@internet.isSa�lheimum 23, 7A                     Tlf.: +354-553 2858IS-104  Reykjava�k                      Mobil: +354-822 0645 On 16. a�ga�. 2015, at 08:31, John Hill john@yclept.wanadoo.co.uk [gcmac] <gcmac@yahoogroups.com> wrote: I consulted Canon during the Yos 2 research into the problem, and they state categorically that they use TWAIN and nothing else to interface their MP Navigator EX software with my printer.Providing I leave Image Capture Extension running, I can use Image Capture with the scanner, but the images are of poorer quality (at least for my purposes) than those obtained with the Canon drivers.It remains to be seen what happens when El Capitan is released, but I imagine they will update the MD5150 drivers. I don’t think it is in their current catalogue, but it is too recent to become obsolescent yet.John.On 15 Aug 2015, at 19:01, Thorsten Lemke lemke@lemkesoft.de [gcmac] <gcmac@yahoogroups.com> wrote:Hello,maybe they use now image capture? Did you try?ThorstenCanon has issued new drivers compatible with Yosemite.

Re: Oh, RATS!!! Yos 4 upsets TWAIN again

Posted: Fri Aug 21, 2015 5:54 pm
by John Hill
For what it’s worth, I have now found out that if I run ExactScan (downloaded on a trial basis) and use it to scan “using the native scanner”, ScanGear opens instantly and will let me Preview. True, it will not let me Scan - the scanner murmurs and then locks. I suspect that ExactScan does not pass the parameters of a destination file back through the TWAIN interface. Perhaps Thorsten can confirm whether it is the job of the calling application to create the destination file (permanent or temporary), or if the scanner driver creates it and passes it to the calling application?However, that is another problem, which I do not propose to solve as I neither need nor can afford ExactScan.But it does show that a third party application can call ScanGear via TWAIN on my iMac without the Image Capture Extension delay. MP Navigator Ex *might* have got away with it because it is Canon software calling Canon software.John. On 16 Aug 2015, at 10:12, Petur Rasmussen prasm@internet.is [gcmac] <gcmac@yahoogroups.com> wrote:I am perfectly able to use twain with the Canon driver. Maybe it uses the special Canon environment set up by Canon on installing the driver.Give it another try.RegardsPetur--------------------------------------------------------Petur Rasmussen            e-mail: prasm@internet.isSa�lheimum 23, 7A                     Tlf.: +354-553 2858IS-104  Reykjava�k                      Mobil: +354-822 0645 On 16. a�ga�. 2015, at 08:31, John Hill john@yclept.wanadoo.co.uk [gcmac] <gcmac@yahoogroups.com> wrote: I consulted Canon during the Yos 2 research into the problem, and they state categorically that they use TWAIN and nothing else to interface their MP Navigator EX software with my printer.Providing I leave Image Capture Extension running, I can use Image Capture with the scanner, but the images are of poorer quality (at least for my purposes) than those obtained with the Canon drivers.It remains to be seen what happens when El Capitan is released, but I imagine they will update the MD5150 drivers. I don’t think it is in their current catalogue, but it is too recent to become obsolescent yet.John.On 15 Aug 2015, at 19:01, Thorsten Lemke lemke@lemkesoft.de [gcmac] <gcmac@yahoogroups.com> wrote:Hello,maybe they use now image capture? Did you try?ThorstenCanon has issued new drivers compatible with Yosemite.